Get the BEST Wisconsin Cheese!

Made with REAL Amish Milk in Cashton, WI

We do not ship our products from April - October.
Sorry for the inconvenience.

The Old Country Cheese Factory is located in the heart of the Amish community in Southwestern Wisconsin. We accept fresh can milk from 230 Amish milk producers who live around Cashton, Hillsboro, Tomah, Wilton, Sylvan, Readstown, Liberty Pole, and Chaseburg. Old Country Cheese, located on County Road D in Cashton, brings in 120,000 pounds of milk a day from over 230 Amish milk producers!

Fresh Wisconsin Cheese

Not only do we make Wisconsin cheese, but we also have a factory outlet store where you can buy all sorts of styles and flavors of cheese.

Cheese Gift Baskets

Old Country Cheese offers a wide variety of Cheese Gift Baskets/Boxes in our store or available to purchase online. Yes! We are happy to prepare gift boxes of Wisconsin cheese for Corporate events and gifts!

Amish Jams

Amish jams and preserves capture the sweet goodness of summer’s fruits to be enjoyed any time of year, on toast, bread, pancakes or just about anything.

Amish Candy

We offer a fantastic assortment of candy and snacks. Some you may not have even heard of and some you probably grew up with. Either way you are guaranteed a treat!

Wisconsin Maple Syrup

Wisconsin is home to some of the best maple trees in the world. These maple trees produce the sap that is turned into all natural maple syrup. We offer locally produced maple syrup in a variety of sizes.

Amish Co-op / Cheese Factory

We make everything from cheese curds to 8 year old cheddar and juusto baked cheese including:

Plain Juusto Cheese
Pepper Juusto Cheese
Muenster Cheese
Colby Cheese
Colby Jack Cheese
Monterey Jack Cheese
Pepper Jack Cheese
Vegetable Jack Cheese
Garlic Cheese
Cheddar Cheese
Cheddar Medium

Cheddar Sharp
2-10 Year Old Cheddar Cheese
Cheddar (chives) "pepper" Cheese
Cheddar Onion Cheese
Cheddar Garlic Cheese
Cheddar Vegetable Cheese
Cheddar Horse Radish Cheese
Bacon Cheddar Cheese
Cheese Curds (plain, garlic and dill)
Onion Jack Cheese

Our cheese store carries over 20 varieties of cheese made right here, as well as many Amish made crafts, candy, jams and maple syrups. You can order our delicious products and unique gift items by browsing our online store today!

Page Summary: Get the best Wisconsin cheese, gift baskets and Amish foods online at Old Country Cheese, with great holiday gift ideas, bulk cheese, gift boxes and gift delivery nationwide. Order online today!

Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC