Home of the World Famous
Muenster Cheese Curds

S502 County Road D
Cashton, WI 54619
Phone: 608-654-5411
Toll Free: 888-320-9469


***April 1st through September 30th***

Please Take Note: All of the items you see are available in our store for in-person shopping ALL YEAR.
Due to the unreliability of shipping services delivery times we can no longer ship during summer months.
We are sorry for this inconvenience and thank you for your understanding.

Shop Our Products


Home » All Products
 
20 oz. Chocolate Chip Cookie Pancake & Waffle Mix
20 oz. Chocolate Chip Cookie Pancake & Waffle Mix
In Stock 9
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pancake and Waffle Mix
Price: $6.95
20 oz. Chocolate Fiesta Pancake & Waffle Mix
20 oz. Chocolate Fiesta Pancake & Waffle Mix
In Stock 10
Chocolate Fiesta Pancake and Waffle Mix
Price: $5.95
20 oz. Peanut Butter Pancake & Waffle Mix
20 oz. Peanut Butter Pancake & Waffle Mix
In Stock 10
Peanut Butter Pancake and Waffle Mix
Price: $6.95
3.5 oz. Mild Beef Jerky
3.5 oz. Mild Beef Jerky
In Stock 14
Tender Mild Beef Jerky
Price: $12.95
6 lb. Muenster Special
6 lb. Muenster Special
In Stock 37
Great Tasting Muenster Cheese at a GREAT low price. Buy a 5 pound block and get it for $3.99 per lb.
Price: $36.00
7 oz. Sweets Salt Water Taffy
7 oz. Sweets Salt Water Taffy
In Stock 8
Sweet's Salt Water Taffy
Price: $4.99
8 oz. Wasabi Peas
8 oz. Wasabi Peas
In Stock 8
8 oz. Wasabi Peas
Price: $4.99
9 oz. Cinnamon Squares
9 oz. Cinnamon Squares
In Stock 4
Cinnamon Squares!
Price: $4.99
9 oz. Malted Milk Balls
9 oz. Malted Milk Balls
In Stock 6
9 oz. Malted Milk Balls
Price: $4.99
9 oz. Spicy Cajun Mix
9 oz. Spicy Cajun Mix
In Stock 9
9 oz. Spicy Cajun Mix
Price: $4.99
Almond Clusters
Almond Clusters
In Stock 19
1 lb. Package of  Almond Clusters awesome homemade Amish candy. Great for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Amish Treats
Amish Treats
In Stock 150
1 lb each of Christmas Cheese (chives), Bacon Fest, Buffalo Wing, and Medium Cheddar Cheese; 1 lb each of Cashew Crunch and Scrunch, and 1 each of Jalapeño & Cheddar and Beef Sausage.                   
Price: $68.95
Assortments
Assortments
In Stock 14
1 lb. Package of awesome Assorted homemade Amish candy. Great for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Bosses Favorite
Bosses Favorite
In Stock 14
1 lb. each of  Bacon Fest , Christmas Cheese (chives), Baby Swiss and Buffalo Wing Cheese; 1 lb. Cashew Crunch and 1 lb. Scrunch
Price: $65.95
Bulk Colby Cheese
Bulk Colby Cheese
In Stock 9
40lbs. Cheese for shipping UPS. Colby Cheese @ $5.99 lb. Free Shipping except to Hawaii, Alaska, or any other country. We ship these items Oct-April UPS.
Price: $239.60
Bulk Colby Jack Cheese
Bulk Colby Jack Cheese
In Stock 5
40lbs. Cheese for shipping by UPS. Colby Jack Cheese @ $5.99 lb. Free Shipping except to Hawaii, Alaska, or any other country. We ship these items Oct-April UPS.
Price: $239.60
Bulk Mild Cheddar Cheese
Bulk Mild Cheddar Cheese
In Stock 8
40 lbs. Cheese for shipping UPS - Mild Cheddar Cheese @ $5.99 lb. Free Shipping except to Hawaii, Alaska, or any other country. We ship these items Oct-April UPS.
Price: $239.60
Bulk Muenster Cheese
Bulk Muenster Cheese
In Stock 5
36 lbs. Cheese for UPS shipping only. Muenster Cheese @ $5.99 lb. Free Shipping except to Hawaii, Alaska, or any other country. We ship these items Oct-April using UPS.
Price: $215.64
« | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | »

© 2014 - 2025 Old Country Cheese, All rights reserved.

Website Design by SusanSullivanDesign.com