Home of the World Famous
Muenster Cheese Curds

S502 County Road D
Cashton, WI 54619
Phone: 608-654-5411
Toll Free: 888-320-9469


***April 1st through September 30th***

Please Take Note: All of the items you see are available in our store for in-person shopping ALL YEAR.
Due to the unreliability of shipping services delivery times we can no longer ship during summer months.
We are sorry for this inconvenience and thank you for your understanding.

Shop Our Products


Home » All Products
 
Juusto Cheese - Plain/ 5 year old
Juusto Cheese - Plain/ 5 year old
In Stock 3
A very tasty treat or snack. Our  Juusto Cheese filled with 5 year old cheddar comes in a 6oz. package.
Price: $5.99
Mail Man Special
Mail Man Special
In Stock 50
1 lb. each of Mild Cheddar and Colby Jack Cheese with 1 - 12 oz. Beef Sausage
Price: $21.99
Maple Nut Cream
Maple Nut Cream
In Stock 13
1# Package of awesome Maple Nut Cream homemade Amish candy. Looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Medium Black Bean Salsa
Medium Black Bean Salsa
In Stock 10
16 oz. Medium Black Bean Salsa, if you are a salsa lover these salsa's are very good! A great gift idea or a tasty treat for yourself.
Price: $8.95
Medium Cherry Salsa
Medium Cherry Salsa
In Stock 8
17 oz. Medium Cherry Salsa, the fruit salsa's are very delicious. Once you have tried them you will order again  A great gift idea or a tasty treat for yourself.
Price: $8.95
Medium Mango Salsa
Medium Mango Salsa
In Stock 8
17 oz. Medium Mango Salsa, the fruit salsa's are very delicious. Once you have tried them you will order again  A great gift idea or a tasty treat for yourself.
Price: $8.95
Medium Pinapple Salsa
Medium Pinapple Salsa
In Stock 20
17 oz. Medium Pineapple Salsa, the fruit salsa's are very delicious. Once you have tried them you will order again  A great gift idea or a tasty treat for yourself.
Price: $8.95
Mild Peach Salsa
Mild Peach Salsa
In Stock 9
17 oz. Mild Peach Salsa, the fruit salsa's are very delicious. Once you have tried them you will order again  A great gift idea or a tasty treat for yourself.
Price: $8.95
Mints
Mints
In Stock 16
1# Package of awesome Mints homemade Amish candy. Looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Muenster Cheese Curds
Muenster Cheese Curds
Based on 4 ratings.
In Stock 0
Try our fantastic Muenster cheese curds. Some people refer to them as squeaky cheese. They are delicious.They come in 10 oz. Bags.
Price: $5.99
Old Country Special
Old Country Special
In Stock 68
1 lb. each of Muenster, Medium Cheddar, Colby and Baby Swiss Cheese and one 12 oz. Beef Sausage
Price: $39.95
Party Box
Party Box
In Stock 53
1 lb. each of Colby, Salami, Muenster, Bacon Fest, Buffalo Wing, Pepper Jack, Baby Swiss and Sharp Cheddar Cheese; 1 lb. Scrunch, and 1 - 12 oz. Jalapeõ & Cheddar Sausage
Price: $99.95
Peanut Clusters
Peanut Clusters
In Stock 19
1# Package of awesome Peanut Clusters homemade Amish candy. Looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Peanut Goodies
Peanut Goodies
In Stock 20
1# Package of awesome Peanut Goodies homemade Amish candy. Looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Perfect Combination
Perfect Combination
In Stock 21
1 lb. each of Mild Cheddar, Baby Swiss Cheese, Colby Cheese, Pepper Jack, Medium Cheddar, Muenster Cheese, Colby Jack, Christmas Cheese (chives) and Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Price: $79.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Chunky Bleu
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Chunky Bleu
In Stock 0
Chunky Bleu Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 7 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Garlic & Herb
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Garlic & Herb
In Stock 6
Garlic & Herb Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 8 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Ghost Pepper
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Ghost Pepper
In Stock 7
Ghost Pepper Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 7 oz.
Price: $5.95
« | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | »

© 2014 - 2025 Old Country Cheese, All rights reserved.

Website Design by SusanSullivanDesign.com